English
  • English
Start savingStart saving
Back to blog
4 min readNovember 16, 2026

IRMAA Letter From Social Security: the Income Year to Check and When to Appeal

An IRMAA letter for 2027 is normally based on your 2025 tax return. If the figures are wrong, you have 60 days to appeal; if your income fell after a life event, ask for a new decision with form SSA-44.

dEssence TeamEditorial @ dEssence
IRMAA Letter From Social Security: the Income Year to Check and When to Appeal

An IRMAA letter for 2027 is normally based on your 2025 tax return. If the figures are wrong, you have 60 days to appeal; if your income fell after a life event, ask for a new decision with form SSA-44.

What the IRMAA letter is

IRMAA stands for income-related monthly adjustment amount. It is an extra amount some people with Medicare pay on top of the standard Part B premium and their Part D drug plan premium. Social Security decides it using income data from the IRS and sends you a letter with the decision.

Which income year the letter uses

Social Security's own manual on the IRMAA tables says the income is based on the tax return from two years before, or three years before if the two-year return is not available. The figure used is modified adjusted gross income, MAGI: your adjusted gross income plus certain tax-exempt income.

Premium yearTax return normally usedIf that return is missing
202620242023
202720252024

So a 2027 letter can reflect a year when you were still working full time, sold a house or took a large retirement account withdrawal. That gap between then and now is why people question the letter.

What to check, line by line

Before deciding anything, read the letter against your own tax return for the year it names:

  1. The premium year. The letter should say which year the surcharge applies to, here 2027.
  2. The tax year used. 2025, or 2024 if the 2025 return was not available.
  3. The income figure. Compare it with the adjusted gross income on that return plus any tax-exempt interest.
  4. Your filing status. Single and married filing jointly use different brackets, so a wrong status changes the result.
  5. The amounts. There is one surcharge for Part B and a separate one for Part D. The Part D amount is on top of your drug plan's own premium.

If every line matches your return and nothing in your life has changed since, the letter is probably right, even if it feels steep.

SituationRouteWhat to send
The income or filing status Social Security used is wrongReconsideration, within 60 daysAppeal request and proof of the correct figures
Your income dropped after a life-changing eventNew initial determinationForm SSA-44 with evidence of the event and the new income
You filed an amended tax returnCall Social SecurityTell them you want IRMAA lowered because of the amended return

The 60-day appeal window

Social Security's manual on IRMAA appeals says you or your representative can request a reconsideration within 60 days of receiving the determination notice. Receiving it is taken to mean 5 days after the date on the letter, unless you can show it arrived later. In practice, count 65 days from the date printed on the letter.

A reconsideration is the first of four appeal levels. If you disagree after it, the next steps go to a Medicare hearing, then review, then federal court.

When form SSA-44 fits

SSA-44 asks Social Security to use a more recent year's income because a life-changing event lowered it. The form lists eight events: marriage, divorce or annulment, the death of your spouse, work stopping or being reduced (two separate boxes, for you or your spouse), the loss of income-producing property, the loss of pension income, and an employer settlement payment. Retiring counts as a work stoppage.

You give the date of the event, your income for the more recent year, and evidence such as a tax return or a letter showing the end of work or pension. Social Security accepts the form online through its upload page, by mail or fax to an office, or at an appointment. Tax advice on what counts as income is a question for a tax professional, not for this checklist.

Two details from the form's instructions are easy to miss. The date of the life-changing event has to fall in the same year as the tax year you ask Social Security to use, or earlier. And if your letter shows no IRMAA at all, there is nothing to lower, so the form is not needed even after a big life change.

The 2027 income brackets and surcharge amounts are printed in your letter. Use those, not figures from older articles.

Keeping the letter and the deadline

IRMAA letters tend to arrive late in the year, next to plan letters and holiday mail, and the 60 days run through January.

dEssence can hold it. Send Tracy a photo or PDF of the letter. She pulls out the income year, the amounts and the letter date from what you sent, and reminds you before the deadline when you ask. She does not file SSA-44 or an appeal, work out your income, or give tax advice.

Frequently asked questions

What year's income is used for 2027 IRMAA?

Normally your 2025 tax return. If it is not available, Social Security uses 2024.

How long do I have to appeal an IRMAA decision?

60 days from receiving the letter. Receipt is assumed to be 5 days after the letter date unless you show otherwise.

Is SSA-44 the same as an appeal?

No. SSA-44 asks for a new decision based on a more recent year after a life-changing event. An appeal, or reconsideration, says the original decision used wrong information.

What counts as a life-changing event for IRMAA?

Marriage, divorce or annulment, death of a spouse, work stopping or being reduced, loss of income-producing property, loss of pension income, and an employer settlement payment.

Related reading