Thanksgiving Grocery Substitutions: Pick Your Backup Before Shopping
For Thanksgiving grocery substitutions, mark each item as replaceable, choose a specific backup or request a refund. Save those choices before shopping starts and answer the shopper in the ordering service.

For Thanksgiving grocery substitutions, decide which items can change, which need a specific backup and which should be refunded if unavailable. Enter those choices in the ordering service before shopping starts, then respond to any shopper messages yourself.
For a meal on November 26, 2026, imagine an order with potatoes, canned pumpkin and a product chosen for a guest's dietary needs. Another suitable potato brand might be fine. The pumpkin needs to match the recipe. The dietary item needs its own ingredient check. One substitution setting for the entire basket cannot express those differences.
Choose a substitution rule for each ingredient
Use three choices as a planning method. The service may name its controls differently, and it may not offer a field for every instruction. Translate your decision into the available product-level settings or notes, then check that the saved order reflects it.
| Choice | Use it when | Example instruction |
|---|---|---|
| Allow a suitable replacement | Several products meet your requirements | Same type of potatoes, enough for the recipe |
| Name one backup | Only a particular alternative works | This specific plain canned pumpkin, in the needed quantity |
| Refund if unavailable | You have no acceptable replacement | No substitute for this item; refund it |
The examples describe a household's decisions, not recommendations about food safety or what every recipe can tolerate. Check your recipe before approving a replacement. Similar-looking packages can contain different ingredients or amounts.
Start with the ingredient that determines whether a dish can be made at all. Give that item a decision before spending time on a garnish. If a refund would leave you without a main part of dinner, decide in advance whether you will buy it elsewhere or use a different dish.
Check size, form and cost before choosing a backup
A replacement should cover the quantity you need. Look at the package size and the total amount in the order, especially if the backup comes in a smaller container. Do not assume one package replaces one package. Work from the amount in the recipe and your own serving plan.
Check the product description as well. Plain canned pumpkin and prepared pie filling are different products; a recognizable label color is not enough. The same caution applies when a recipe calls for a particular preparation or texture. If you are unsure whether a replacement works, choose a product you know or plan another dish.
Set a spending limit you are comfortable with. A replacement can change the total, and an acceptable brand does not automatically mean an acceptable price. Read the order's estimate again after editing and inspect the final receipt when the groceries arrive.
For allergies or other dietary restrictions, review the actual label and use the advice you normally follow for that guest. Ask the guest when you need clarification. A shopper's suggestion or an assistant's summary cannot establish that a product is safe for someone with an allergy. Choose no substitution when you cannot confidently approve an alternative.
Check who is fulfilling the order
Kroger's delivery FAQ explains that orders may be fulfilled by Kroger or a third-party service. It allows customers to indicate whether substitutions are acceptable and describes an option to receive substitution notifications and approve or reject them.
For a submitted next-day order, that FAQ says changes are possible until the shopper starts picking. Once an Instacart shopper has begun, it directs customers to chat with the shopper for help. This is Kroger's stated process for that order type. It is not a universal cutoff for every grocery service, location or delivery method.
Open your own order and find the applicable editing controls. Check the fulfillment service, shopping status and notification settings. A delivery time describes when groceries are expected to reach you; it does not necessarily describe how long you can edit the order.
If you cannot enter a specific backup, look for an item note or the service's help option. Do not rely on an instruction in a personal note that the shopper cannot see. After saving a change, reopen the order and make sure it stayed there.
Plan for the message that arrives while you are busy
Decide who will watch the ordering service during shopping. If another adult is handling dinner, agree who will answer so the shopper does not get conflicting instructions. Keep the critical replacement choices short enough to read on a phone.
When a suggestion arrives, check the item, size, quantity and price before replying in the service. If it affects a dietary requirement, inspect the information needed for that decision. If the offered choice does not work, use the rejection or refund option available for that order rather than hoping a note elsewhere will be noticed.
After delivery, compare the groceries and receipt with the dishes you still plan to cook. Check any essential replacement before starting the recipe. If there is an issue, use the ordering service's support process while the order details are easy to find.
Save the decisions and set a time to review them
Before shopping starts, complete this check:
- Choose allow, specific backup or refund for each critical item.
- Confirm the backup's amount, product details and acceptable cost.
- Review dietary restrictions using the actual product information.
- Save the settings in the service and confirm who will answer messages.
- Choose a time to reopen the order before its editing window closes.
You can save a screenshot of the order and your chosen replacements to Tracy in dEssence, then ask for a reminder to review them at a time you select. Tracy keeps the context you provide. She does not read the shopper chat, check allergens or approve replacements. Make those decisions in the ordering service yourself.
Frequently asked questions
Should I allow every Thanksgiving grocery substitution?
No. Decide item by item. Flexible ingredients may have several acceptable replacements, while a recipe-critical or dietary-specific item may need one named backup or no substitution.
Can I change a Kroger next-day order after submitting it?
Yes, its delivery FAQ says you can modify it until the shopper starts picking. Check your order's current status and fulfillment method; after shopping begins, follow the service's instructions for contacting the shopper.
Does requesting a refund solve an unavailable ingredient?
It solves the unwanted-purchase decision, but you still need a plan for the missing ingredient. Decide whether you will obtain it elsewhere or change the dish before the order arrives.
Can Tracy answer the shopper for me?
No. You respond in the grocery service. You can ask Tracy to remind you to review the order, using the screenshot and instructions you chose to save.
Retailer information checked November 3, 2026. This independent guide is not affiliated with Kroger or Instacart; their trademarks belong to their owners.